CONSIDERATIONS ON RUSSIAN PHILOSOPHY TODAY
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.21618/fil2531094rKeywords:
contemporary Russian philosophy, tasks of philosophy, philosophy and society, ideology and philosophy, role of the philosopherAbstract
Contemporary Russian philosophy is experiencing an identity crisis, reflecting the tensions between ideology and intellectual autonomy, as clearly demonstrated by the recent conflict. The article analyzes the role of philosophy in the current context, highlighting how it is used both to legitimize political power and to promote independent critical thought. The introduction presents a brief discussion on the difficulties of defining a “Russian philosophy”, no longer confined to national borders but spread across an intellectual diaspora, including philosophers both in Russia and abroad. A central point of the discussion is the concept of the transition from the post-Soviet phase to the contemporary era. The author highlights how this transformation has fragmented the Russian philosophical landscape, divided between Soviet ideological legacies—concerning the role and tasks of the philosopher in society—and new cultural demands. The “philosophy of the front”, developed in contexts such as the 2022 roundtable in Moscow, represents an emblematic example: through themes like the “clash of civilizations”, philosophical thought reconnects to propaganda practices, adapted to the current context’s needs. However, the author emphasizes the complexities of this process, as the contemporary context makes it difficult to control the philosophical discourse entirely. A relevant aspect is the reflection on the “philosophy of war” and the ensuing debates, which reveal the polarization between those who criticize the inability of contemporary Russian philosophy to directly engage with events like the war in Donbass and those who see these conflicts as an opportunity to reaffirm Russian imperial identity. The idea of a “sovereign philosophy”, detached from external Western influences, also represents an attempt to respond to the current crisis, although it risks becoming yet another tool of power. While philosophy within Russia is called to define new horizons and directions, often influenced by nationalist rhetoric, spaces of critical resistance are also emerging. The Independent Institute of Philosophy, founded by dissident philosophers, and the work Pered licom katastrofy [Facing the Catastrophe] (2023) demonstrate how philosophical thought can still question freedom, responsibility, and truth, opposing ideological corruption. The author underscores these efforts as attempts to build a contemporary Russian philosophy capable of engaging with the global and multipolar world. Thinkers like Dobrochotov emphasize the philosopher's task of preserving fundamental concepts such as rationality, freedom, and responsibility, opposing linguistic and ideological corruption. According to this view, philosophy must transcend ideological divisions to rediscover its existential and anthropological mission, as indicated by Skorobogackij, who calls for a renewal of thought to respond to contemporary challenges. The future development of Russian philosophy will then depend on its ability to navigate this transition while maintaining a balance between tradition and critical renewal.
References
Arendt, H. (1990) Philosophy and Politics. Social Research. 57 (1), 73–103.
Choružij, S. S. (2005) Očerki sinergijnoj antropologii, Moskva, Institut filosofii, teologii i istorii sv. Fomy.
DeBlasio, A. (2014) The End of Russian Philosophy: Tradition and Transition at the Turn of the 21st Century, Basingstoke & New York, Palgrave Macmillan.
DeBlasio, A. (2021) Foreword: Russian Philosophy as Anthology. In Sergeev, M., Chumakov, A., Theis, M. (eds.), Russian Philosophy in the Twenty-First Century: An Anthology. Leiden; Boston, Brill Rodopi, pp.IX–XIV.
Demčenko, N. (2022) Institut filosofii RAN požalovalsja na kampanii “psevdopatriotov”. RBC.ru. 23/12/2022. URL: https://www.rbc.ru/society/23/12/2022/63a575f49a79474c2bf10339 (ultimo accesso 24/12/2023).
Dioletta Siclari, A. (2020) La filosofia russa (Essay review). Noctua. 7 (2), 336–408.
Dobrochotov, A. (2023), Razgovor o vojne, tiranii i konce istorii. In Plotnikov, N. (ed.), Pered licom katastrofy: sbornik statej. Berlin; Münster; Wien; Zürich; London, LIT Verlag, pp.149–164.
Epštein, M. (1998) Main Trends of Contemporary Russian Thought. Paideia. Contemporary Philosophy. URL: https://www.bu.edu/wcp/Papers/Cont/ContEpst.htm (ultimo accesso 22/12/2023).
Epštein, M. (2019) The Phoenix of Philosophy: Russian Thought of the Late Soviet Period (1953-1991), New York, Bloomsbury Academic.
Epštein, M. (2023) Russkij antimir. Politika na grani Apokalipsa, New York, FrancTireur USA.
Golubeva, A. (2021) V Institute filosofii RAN smenilsja direktor. Rossijskie učenye nedelju protestovali – i dobilis’ uspecha. BBC. Russkaja služba. 28/11/2021. URL: https://www.bbc.com/russian/news-59810516 (ultimo accesso 24/10/24).
Gujsenov, A. A. (2023) O toždestve russkoj filosofii i filosofii v Rossii. Filosofskij žurnal. 3 (16), 5–16.
Jakovleva, E. (2022) Specoperaciju na Ukraine obsudili na kruglom stole frontovye filosofy. Rosskijskaja gazeta, 30.03.2022. URL: https://rg.ru/2022/03/30/reg-cfo/specoperaciiu-na-ukraine-obsudili-na-kruglom-stole-frontovye-filosofy.html (ultimo accesso 28/12/2023).
Kara-Murza, A. A. (2023) Filosofija v Rossii i russkaja filosofskaja publicistika. Filosofskij žurnal. 16 (3), 17–23.
Korobov-Latyncev, A. (2021) Filosofija vojny i filosofskie vojny i Rossii. Russkaja istina, 31.07.2021. URL: https://politconservatism.ru/articles/filosofiya-vojny-ifilosofskie-vojny-v-rossii (ultimo accesso 12/12/2023).
Korobov-Latyncev, A. (2022) Filosof i vojna. O russkoj voennoj filosofii, Moskva, ID “Russkaja filosofija”.
Laruelle, M. (2019) Back From Utopia: How Donbas Fighters Reinvent Themselves in a Post-Novorossiya Russia. Nationalities Papers. Special Issue on the Donbas Conflict. 47 (5), 719–733.
Laruelle, M. (2022) Nužna li mobilizacii filosofija vojny? “Noev kovčeg”, “giperborejcy” i “velikoe obnulenie” na rynke propagandy. Re.Russia, 04/10/2022. URL: https://re-russia.net/analytics/024/ (ultimo accesso 18/04/2024).
Lektorskij, V. A. (2009), O filosofii Rossii vtoroj poloviny XX v. Voprosy filosofii, 11/08/2009, URL: http://vphil.ru/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=49 (ultimo accesso 12/01/2024).
Lektorsky V., Bykova M. (eds.) (2019) Philosophical Thought in Russia in the Second Half of the Twentieth Century. A Contemporary View from Russia and Abroad. New York, Bloomsbury Academic.
Leskova, N. (2022) Rossijskaja filosofija nachoditsja na pod’’eme. Kommersant’’, 13/03/2022. URL https://www.kommersant.ru/doc/5236641 (ultimo accesso 18/04/2024).
Maiatsky, M. (2022) Contemporary Philosophy in Russia (1991–2022). In Minakov, M. (ed.) Philosophy Unchained. Developments in Post-Soviet Philosophical Thought, Stuttgart, Ibide-Verlag, pp.211–282.
Maslin, M. A., Medenica, V., Serbinenko, V. V. & Sineokaja Ju. V. (2016) Russkaja filosofija v Rossii i za rubežom. Filosofskij žurnal. 9 (4), 161–175.
Medvedev, S. (2023) Julija Sineocakja: Na samom dele russkoaja filosofija ne izučena. Svoboda. 24/12/2023. URL: https://www.svoboda.org/a/yuliya-sineokaya-na-samomdele-russkaya-filosofiya-ne-izuchena-/32744271.html (ultimo accesso 24/12/2023).
Minakov, M. (2022) Philosophy Unchained. Developments in Post-Soviet Philosophical Thought, Stuttgart, Ibide-Verlag.
Oppo, A. (2021) Does a "Russian Philosophy" Exist? The Boundaries and Nature of a Question. Solov’evskie issledovanija. 70 (2), 47–67.
Perini, G. (1989) La filosofia russa. Divus Thomas. 92 (1/2), 150–178.
Petjakševa, N. I. (2006) Ponjatie “Nacional’naja filosofija” v kontekste komparativistiki. Vestnik Rossijskogo universiteta družby narodov. Serija: Filosofija. 1, 160–169.
Pivovarov, D. V. (2016) O svobode filosofskich i religioznych mnenij v sovremennoj Rossii. In Loginov, A. V., Tomjuk, O. N. (eds.), Filosofija v XXI veke: vyzovy, cennosti, perspektivy. Sbornik naučnych statej. Ekaterinburg, Maks-info, pp.206–211.
Poljakov, L. (2022) Rossijskaja filosofija – bol’šaja pustynja. Kommersant’, 13/03/2022. URL: https://www.kommersant.ru/doc/5236639?from=doc_vrez (ultimo accesso 24/12/2023).
Pružinin, B. I. (2014), Filosofija Rossii segodnja: tendencii i perspektivy. Gumanitarnie issledovanija v Vostočnoj Sibiri i na Dal’nem Vostoke. 3 (29), 6–12.
Sagatovskij V. N. (2009), Est’ li buduščee u russkoj filosofii?. Vestnik Russkoj christianskoj gumanitarnoj akademii. 10 (1), 121–132.
Skorobogackij, V. V. (2016) Piknik na obočine, ili filosofija v uslovijach rossijskoj okolosovremennosti. In Loginov, A. V., Tomjuk, O. N. (eds.), Filosofija v XXI veke: vyzovy, cennosti, perspektivy. Sbornik naučnych statej, Ekaterinburg, Maks-info, 32–40.
Smirnov, A. (2021) Current Objectives of Russian Philosophy. Social Sciences, 52 (4), 4–20.
Kirjuchin, D. (2022) Filosofskij process v postsovetskoj Ukraine. Ideology and Politics Journal. 1 (20), 301–326.
Solov’ev, E. Ju. (1998) Filosofskij žurnalizm šestidesjatych: zavoevanija, obol’ščenija, nedodelannye dela. In Lektorskij V. A. (ed.) Filosofija ne končaetsja… Iz istorii otečestvennoj filosofii. XX v.: v 2 kn. Kn. II: 60-80-e gg., Moskva, Rosspen, 108–118.
Špet, G. (2008) Očerk razvitija russkoj filosofii (ed. by T. G. Ščedrina). Moskva, Rosspen.
Steila, D. (2014) Individuo e cultura nel pensiero di Merab K. Mamardašvili. In Antonelli, E., Martinengo, A. (a cura di), Confini dell'estetica. Studi in onore di Roberto Salizzoni. Roma, Aracne, pp.75–87.
Stepin, V. (1998) Russian Philosophy Today. Social Sciences, 29 (1). URL: https://ciaotest.cc.columbia.edu/olj/socsci/socsci_98stepin.html (ultimo accesso 12/01/2024).
Vyšeslavcev, B. (1955) Večnoe v russkoj filosofii. New York, izd. imeni Čechova.
Yulina, N. S. (1994) Philosophy in Russia Today. Metaphilosophy. Special issue: Philosophy in Eastern Europe. 25 (2/3), 117–131.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.